The Yanomamo believe that it is 
acceptable to murder another person out of revenge, if you have lost 
something and in killing another you will gain something. Much like an 
eye for an eye. In the Western culture the only reasons permitted to 
kill another is by self defense. The only accepted revenge killings in 
the Western culture, which is only accepted in some parts, is the death 
penalty. 
If a member of your kin or village 
is murdered that person's body is burned and the ashes are consumed by 
the women. They do this to pump up the men to get them ready to avenge 
the death. However, sometimes the men of the village are so stricken by 
the death that they become cowards seeking refuge in neighboring 
villages where they take them in to take advantage of their women. If 
they do go on these revenge killings there is a small group of men that 
go, maybe 10 to 20. But they dwindle down as the men start to get 
nervous as they get closer to where they believe the target of their 
revenge killing is. They will travel a good 4 day walk to find their 
enemy, and once there they might not even kill the person they are 
looking for but the first man they see. They will only return home once 
the revenge killing is complete or if the enemy was not where they 
believed them to be.
There are benefits to becoming an unokais even though the risk of death is high. As an unokais you are more likely to have more women marry them and have more children than non-unokais. With this can develop a large kin
 making the villege grow. With survival of the fittest and the unokais 
reproducing more offspring to their likeness, that village should have 
more unokais. The village could grow and gain a substantial amount of 
power having numbers and fighters taking the control of the Yanomamo 
people. The revenge killings start with a death of a kin member, with 
such love and pride of their kin the unokais can protect their loved 
ones. being the strongest, largest village could prevent future revenge 
killings to be inflected on them. For the non-unokias they are less 
likely to see violence, however there is also a high amount of 
non-unokias that are murdered by violence. They have a less likely 
chance to find a mate because they do not go out on revenge killings and
 can't force or show off for the opposite sex. The benefits for the 
unokais greatly out weigh the non-unokais for this culture. Unokais are 
strong, brave, aggressive worriers that are idolized in their culture 
where the non-unokais would be equivalent to the skinny, nerdy guy 
living in his parents basement that never leaves due to agoraphobia.
The Yanomamo do not have a political structure like the Western culture, they are primitive without a written language.
 They do not have laws, or people to enforce these laws. They do have a 
structure which is basic, but necessary for people especially with 
numbers like theirs. They have 15,000 individuals living within 200 
politically independent communities. The person in charge is called the 
"big one" they are the head of the largest descent group within the 
village. If there is another descent group the same size both heads will
 be cross married and be the leader. Most of the leaders are polygamist,
 but other members of the village can be polygamists. This insures many 
offspring and the continuation of the Yamomamo.
After reading about they glory 
given to the the unokais I can see how murder is outlawed. This revenge 
killing is such a horrible, perpetual cycle that never ends. But with 
all the murder and hate comes fame and glory to those that have the 
courage to go out and avenge the death. They get the women and opportunity to 
reproduce. Though people may by distinct nature not want to kill there 
are outside influences that change a person's mind, like a murder of a 
loved one and a culture that deems is acceptable to take revenge on that
 person.
I really liked the ending of your post! You saw how terrible an harsh these revenge killings were but you also the benefit and positive things that come out of these raids. I think you did a really good job explaining everything too!
ReplyDeleteI think your comment about the system of revenge killings as being "horrible" is slightly ethnocentric. Compared to the massive wars industrialized nations wage and the millions that day because of them, this small skirmishes are hardly anything at all. There are real benefits of taking part in the revenge killing system and not all deaths are necessarily avenged, with the political elite deciding as a council which killings will be reciprocated. In my mind, the cycle of revenge killings would be much more appealing than the large-scale wars that our fought within our own society.
ReplyDeleteGood job identifying the death penalty as a form of revenge killing.
ReplyDelete"...the non-unokais would be equivalent to the skinny, nerdy guy living in his parents basement that never leaves due to agoraphobia."
Thanks for the chuckle! That was perfect!
In section #4, I was looking for a description of the way the revenge killings shape these four aspects of the Yanomamo culture. You describe them, but not the connection with revenge killings.
Great final paragraph. Good analysis and discussion.
I like that you called the death penalty a western version of revenge killing, I didn't even think of that, but I believe you are correct. I wonder if the doctor who preforms the execution has ever thought of it that way.
ReplyDelete